- Aetna Healthcare (Newark-Wayne does not participate with the Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan)
- CareIQ
- Cigna Healthcare
- ElderONE
- Emblem Health
- Empire Plan
- Excellus BCBS
- Fidelis Care of NY
- First Niagara Business Works
- Health Republic
- HealthNow NY
- Humana
- Independent Health
- Lifetime Benefits (formerly RMSCO)
- Magnacare
- Martin's Point - US Family Health Plan
- Medicare
- MetraComp
- Multi Plan
- MVP Healthcare
- North American Administrators
- NY Medicaid
- OneCall Medical
- Pomco
- TriCare
- United Healthcare
- Value Options (Behavioral Health)
- Wellcare of New York
- YourCare Health Plan